Digital Procurement & Estimating

Bill of Quantities vs Schedule of Rates: Which Pricing Basis Fits a New-Home Job

Three pricing bases hand the quantity number to three different people. Who carries the risk under a BOQ, a schedule of rates and a lump sum, and how that shapes trade quotes.

· DDDI Built Environment Research

Bill of Quantities vs Schedule of Rates: Which Pricing Basis Fits a New-Home Job

A bill of quantities is a measured list of work that a tenderer prices item by item. A lump sum is a single fixed price for a defined scope. A schedule of rates is a priced list of units in which the quantity is measured as the work proceeds. They are not competing formats. They are competing answers to one question: who pays when the quantity turns out to be wrong.

A measured quantity list asks a trade to price someone else's measurement. A schedule of rates asks them to hold a rate while the quantity is measured as work proceeds. A lump sum hands them the risk outright.


Key Takeaways

  • The document name does not allocate the risk. The remeasurement clause does. A bill can be priced at rates, or priced and fixed.
  • A bill of quantities leaves measurement risk with whoever prepared it, normally the client or their quantity surveyor, but only where the contract adjusts for actual quantities.
  • A schedule of rates keeps the rate and lets the total follow measurement, so the principal pays for what is built.
  • A lump sum transfers quantity risk to the contractor, which is why a trade filling in an unmeasured bill takes the risk without pricing it.
  • On a new home the practical win is one frozen quantity list every trade prices, because that makes two quotes comparable.

The Difference Is the Remeasurement Clause, Not the Document

Both are often prepared in the same format, from the same drawings, by the same person. What separates them is whether the quantities are measured again after the contract is signed.

Main Roads Western Australia states the test: if the quantities of a significant number of items may vary, the document should be termed a schedule of rates; if they will not vary, a bill of quantities (Main Roads WA SMM, January 2024, cl 2.2). Schedules of rates are re-measured; bill items are not, apart from provisional quantities (cl 3.3.4, 3.3.5).

The contract does the rest. AS 4000-1997 states that quantities in a bill of quantities or a schedule of rates are estimated quantities only (cl 2.4), and allows a bill to form part of the contract or be excluded from it (cl 2.2). Where the actual quantity differs, a lump sum accepted for that item makes the difference a deemed variation, while an accepted rate applies to the greater or lesser quantity within stated limits of accuracy (cl 2.5). Clause numbering is from the 1997 edition; Standards Australia published AS 4000:2025, which restated these provisions.

The document is a container. The remeasurement provision is the decision. For what a bill contains, see our guide to the bill of quantities.


Who Carries the Quantity Risk Under Each Basis

A bill with measured quantities puts quantity risk on the preparer. A schedule of rates puts it on the principal, in that the final sum follows measurement. A lump sum puts it on the contractor.

"Lump sum transfers quantity risk from the Employer to the Contractor" is stated plainly in industry commentary (CMGuide). A construction law note puts it in terms of price movement: in a lump sum the price will not alter when quantities differ, whereas in a measured contract the sum is adjusted up or down (Mead, Australian Construction Law Newsletter #79, 2001).

BasisWho carries quantity riskWhat moves the final sum
Bill of quantities, priced at ratesThe party that prepared the measurementThe remeasured quantity
Bill of quantities, priced and fixedThe contractor, once the sum is fixedVariations only
Schedule of ratesThe principal, through the measured totalThe measured quantity, within stated limits
Lump sum, no quantities issuedThe contractorVariations only

Two things are easy to miss. The risk of a wrong measurement is not the risk of more work than expected; a remeasured schedule handles the second, while a take-off error remains someone's mistake. And a schedule of rates is less structured than a bill, with no fixed quantities expected to be met (Holding Redlich, 2022).


How Trades Actually Price a Bill of Quantities

Most trades price the lines they recognise, apply rates built on their own labour and supply costs, and carry their risk allowance inside the rate. A priced bill is not a set of comparable unit rates.

Overhead and margin land wherever the trade normally puts them, some in unit rates and some in preliminaries. For example, two concrete rates of $430 per cubic metre and $465 can describe the same underlying cost once you know what each includes (Estimating Australia).

Tender enquiries issued with a bill often state the quantities are provisional and the subcontractor takes full responsibility. A quantity surveyor's widely circulated warning: "lots of Subcontractors will complete the BOQ without having done their own measure, expecting the quantities are the risk of the Main Contractor, only to later find out they've signed up to a lump sum contract" (Sean Gray, LinkedIn, October 2024).

To price a bill rather than fill one in: price every line, keep allowances separate, state exclusions, and check the quantities before converting rates into a fixed price. That conversion is the moment the risk moves. Scaleline's guide covers how to read a bill of quantities line by line, and our guide to quoting software for builders covers what happens to those prices next.

Scaleline is a DDDI Group company, and DDDI Group publishes this article. Links to Scaleline are related-party referrals, not independent recommendations. Scaleline measures new homes from drawings and does not price them; it is not an AIQS-certified quantity surveying practice.


Why a Shared, Frozen Quantity List Makes Quotes Comparable

If every trade prices the same frozen quantities, a higher quote is a higher rate. If each measures its own scope, a higher quote might just be a bigger job.

A builder returns $1.82 million and another $1.88 million. It looks like a $60,000 gap until you notice the first carries $120,000 in provisional sums against the second's $60,000, that one excludes scaffolding and temporary power, and one priced 36 weeks against the other's 44. That is Estimating Australia's worked example, and it shows why tenders need levelling before comparison.

A quote can differ on the quantity, the scope interpretation, or the rate. Only the third is a competitive difference. Levelling removes the first two by adding back exclusions, resolving provisional items, and aligning GST and supply terms (VIABUILD).

Without a shared list the outcome is predictable. The earthmover excludes subfloor spoil removal. The carpenter excludes craneage into a tight backyard. The plumber excludes slab reinstatement after a new sewer branch. Each exclusion is rational, each lands back on the builder, and the numbers no longer describe one house.

The fix need not be elaborate: the column set and line rules of a new-home BOQ applied consistently, with everyone pricing the same revision. If the difference between take-off, BOQ and estimate is unclear, settle that first.


Which Basis Fits a New-Home Job

A single new home let to a head contractor is normally a lump sum, and the contractor carries the quantity risk. A builder pricing the same home from trades gets more value from a measured quantity list, sent to each trade with the basis stated in writing.

The Australian measurement standard is the Australian and New Zealand Standard Method of Measurement, published by AIQS; the 2022 edition is an update to the 2018 edition (NZIQS guidance notes). Full bills measured to it are uncommon on small residential jobs, and abridged bills and builders' quantities are what the market uses (VIABUILD). Australian research has tracked the decline in standard-method bills (Davis, Love and Baccarini, Construction Innovation 9(2), 2009).

What belongs in the trade enquiry is short: whether the quantities are the trade's risk or yours, which revision applies, what you are supplying, and what you excluded. For licensing and insurance, see licensed and insured trade quotes for developers.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a bill of quantities and a schedule of rates?

A bill lists measured quantities for each item of work, which tenderers price. A schedule of rates lists rates with quantities measured as work proceeds. The test is whether the quantities may vary.

Who carries the quantity risk under a bill of quantities?

Whoever prepared the measurement, provided the contract adjusts for actual quantities. Where the contract instead fixes a lump sum against those quantities, the contractor carries it.

Is a priced bill of quantities the same as a lump sum?

No. It depends whether the contract fixes the sum or the rates. Under AS 4000-1997 a bill may form part of the contract or be excluded entirely (cl 2.2); AS 4000:2025 restates the same choice.

How do you price a bill of quantities?

Price every line, keep allowances separate, state exclusions, and check the quantities before converting rates into a fixed price. Conversion is what moves the risk onto you.

Does a schedule of rates remove quantity risk from the contractor?

Only to the extent the contract remeasures. Within stated limits of accuracy the rate applies to the actual quantity; outside them the difference is a variation.


The Basis Is a Risk Instrument

The pricing basis decides who pays when the measurement is wrong. That is a commercial decision before a document choice.

Three questions settle it. Can the job be measured accurately now? Should the party who measured it carry the cost of being wrong? Can the trade verify the quantities for a reasonable effort? If not, the trade prices a risk allowance instead.

Scaleline locks the quantities for a new home first, then up to three vetted trades price that same measured list, so a higher quote is a higher rate rather than a bigger job. New homes only, 24 to 48 hours from plans-usable confirmation, fixed fee excluding GST: $449 per trade, $1,290 for a whole home, or $3,900 per month for three whole homes with each extra at $990. See trade quotes for builders.

Scaleline is a DDDI Group company, and DDDI Group publishes this article. Links to Scaleline are related-party referrals, not independent recommendations. Scaleline measures new homes from drawings and does not price them; it is not an AIQS-certified quantity surveying practice.

This guide is researched and edited by the DDDI Built Environment Research desk, which publishes industry research on property development and construction in Australia. It is fact-checked against primary sources before publication, and corrections can go to the research desk through the contact page. The editorial standard behind these articles is described on DDDI's about page.

Get Trade Quotes